Everything that changes a result, roughly in order of how much it matters. The percentages are what the match engine actually does, measured or read from its code, so you can decide where your time goes.
1. The players you pick
- Ability and attributes. The biggest factor by far. A strong side at home against a weak one wins about 75–80% of the time.
- Playing them where they play. Every player is natural, accomplished or competent in certain positions (the Positions card on his profile, and the ring on the tactics board). An unfamiliar spot in the same line costs about 7% of his effectiveness; a different line costs about 25%. A spot he has played a fair amount costs much less, about 2–7%.
- Roles. Each role suits an attribute profile: a target man needs heading and strength, a ball-winner needs tackling and work rate. The role list on the board shows how well each player fits.
- Fitness. A tired player plays up to 40% below himself, and fitness drops during a match. Rotate in busy spells.
- Injuries and bans. A red card is a three-match ban, a second yellow one match, and there are bans at five and ten yellows in a season.
2. Form and mood
- Morale is worth about 1% per point either side of content. It comes from playing time against what each player expects, results, wages and promises kept.
- On the day, each side gets a random swing of a few percent. Inconsistent players swing more, so some games are lost whatever you do.
- New arrivals from abroad play slightly below themselves for their first three months or so while they settle.
3. Where and who
- Home advantage: about 45% home wins, 24% draws and 31% away wins between equal sides.
- The opponent's approach. Computer managers set up by the gap in reputation: far stronger sides press and push on, far weaker ones sit deep and go direct. The pre-match preview shows what to expect.
- The league. Each league plays to its real-world scoring level, from about 2.1 goals a game in Argentina to 3.2 in the Netherlands and Germany. A one-goal lead is worth more in a tight second tier than in a free-scoring top flight.
- Mismatches. A lower-league side in a cup tie packs its box and gets a few chances on the break, as in real life.
4. Tactics
- Formation. The defence, midfield and attack bars under the pitch show where you're strong or thin. A shape that leaves your best players out, or out of position, costs more than any instruction gains.
- Team instructions (line, pressing, tempo, tackling, width, passing, risk): fit them to your players and the opponent. A high line with slow defenders is asking for trouble; direct passing beats a high press.
- A shape with the ball as well as without it, roles, individual instructions, set-piece takers and a captain.
- Plans A, B and C: save set-ups and switch in one click during a match.
The tactics guide goes through every option.
5. Preparation
- Analysts write an opposition report for your next game. Reading it sharpens everyone a little; applying its suggestions sharpens them more. A top analyst, followed fully, is worth about 4.5% to every player's match attributes: a few points of win rate.
- Scouts tell you about players, not matches, but knowing an opponent's danger men helps you set up.
- Pre-season friendlies bring fitness up and let you try shapes and new signings before it counts.
6. During the match
- Substitutions: five, plus one in extra time. Fresh legs matter late on.
- Shouts change instructions for about ten minutes and then wear off.
- Team talks at half-time and full-time: the right tone for the scoreline lifts the side; the wrong one deflates it.
- Auto-pause on goals, injuries, red cards and half-time, so you can react in the moment.
7. Over a season
- Coaching and training develop players; hard training develops faster but brings knocks.
- Young players need minutes. Wonderkids only become world-class with games, ideally at a big club.
- Depth. A thin squad loses its points in December, not August. The depth chart flags the thin spots in your formation.
- Keep promises about playing time, and pay players what they're worth.
What doesn't matter
The weather and the referee on the walk-out card are there for atmosphere. They don't change the result.